top of page
Search

Mamdani squirms when asked directly about remarks he made on Oct. 7

58 minutes ago
2 min read
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani questioned on his response to the Oct. 7 anniversary.
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani questioned on his response to the Oct. 7 anniversary.

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani drew widespread criticism early last month over his official statements made on Oct. 7, three years after the brutal Hamas terror attack against Israel. Many blasted Mamdani for "tone-deaf" social media posts that were seen as trying to "hijack" the grim anniversary and use the occasion to accuse Israel of committing a genocide in Gaza.


At the time, Mamdani largely avoided addressing the criticism, but at the New York Times Dealbook Summit in New York City on Wednesday, he was confronted with the issue head on.


"The head of the Reform Jewish movement (had) said at the time that they thought that the statement made New Yorkers less safe. And then there was a rabbi who said — they called himself a fan of yours — he said, 'Can we just have one day?'" Dealbook Summit moderator Andrew Ross Sorkin told Mamdani. "And I'm curious, again, about the language you use. And the reason I mention it is, you know, 53%, I think, of hate crimes in New York City are against Jews," Sorkin continued. "My question is: Would you ever think about sending out one tweet on Oct. 7, saying how terrible what happened on Oct. 7 was, and then waiting till Oct. 8 to say how terrible you think Israel has handled the situation?"


Sorkin's question prompted a round of applause from the live audience, and Mamdani was noticeably uncomfortable as he squirmed in his seat and struggled to gather his thoughts to form a coherent response. Mamdani then went on to again make the false claim that Israel is committing a genocide in Gaza, which Sorkin did not push back on. 


"Let me say it this way. When the Israeli government is conducting a genocide of Palestinians, oftentimes the defense that will be given, no matter what day that it's asked about, will be the relationship to Oct. 7," Mamdani responded. "My point being, this is a day that is not only a horrific war crime. It is also a day that has been used as a justification for all that followed it. And it is in that day that it is important, like in any day, to mourn the totality of its impact."


Sorkin did press Mamdani on "the other side of that argument," and Mamdani insisted that he understood that point of view, but that he stood by his decision to mention the Oct. 7 terror attack and his criticism of Israel's response to it on the same day.


"I have a politics of universality. Whenever I'm asked about 'Why do you support Palestinian freedom or Palestinian rights?' I speak about the importance of extending these same values, of empathy. And that is who I am," Mamdani said. Watch a clip from the interview below.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page